SnapTags: A Competitor in 2-D Barcodes
by Andres Echenique
Here are eight things to consider when determining which mobile interaction to use:
- Branding
SnapTags incorporate a company’s brand logo into the tag, enabling immediate brand recognition. QR codes offer minimal branding space, and customizing them requires additional testing to guarantee optimal scanning performance.
Winner: SnapTags
- Speed of Response
While QR codes only require scanning and responding, SnapTags ask that people snap, send, wait for a response, and then interact. The SnapTag reader app levels the playing field by speeding up this process, making the experience arguably the same.
Winner: Draw
- Reach
SnapTags can reach people who do not own smartphones. By utilizing only cameras and text messaging, users can engage via SMS conversations. QR codes can only be used by smartphone users who own a QR code reader.
Winner: If using an SMS campaign, SnapTags. If not, it’s a draw.
- Price
SnapTags is a service provided by SpyderLynk, meaning only they can create them and the process includes both set-up and participation fees. QR codes, on the other hand, are free and can be created on many different sites.
Winner: QR Codes
- Coding Turnaround
While QR codes can be made instantly by generating them on many websites, SpyderLynk takes at least two days to create and distribute SnapTags. This might not have a major impact on planned campaigns, but it does affect any last-minute decision to incorporate them.
Winner: QR Codes
- Recognition
More people are familiar with and know how to interact with QR codes because their unique checkerboard designs are hard to miss on print advertisements. SnapTag’s brand-focused designs risk being interpreted as regular logos, potentially resulting in a poor response rate.
Winner: QR Codes
- App Accessibility
There are hundreds of apps that can read QR codes, including apps with additional functions and features like Google Goggles. This allows QR codes to be scanned more often by users in comparison to SnapTags, which can only be read by the SnapTag app available only for Android or iOS users.
Winner: QR Codes
- Analytics
SpyderLynk can record the number of times a SnapTag is scanned and the number of users who engage in communication with the company. QR codes provide some level of measuring metrics, but are limited to those who engage and visit a web page.
Winner: SnapTags
Unless you’re using an SMS campaign or brand recognition is a high priority, our recommendation for now is to use QR codes. Both strategies excel and falter in different aspects, and determining which works better is dependent on the audience you are trying to reach and the results you want to achieve.
Senior Partner
Eric Mower + Associates
Phone: (315) 413-4310
aechenique at mower dot com
About EMAbstracts
EMAbstracts is a quarterly newsletter published by Eric Mower + Associates, offering marketing insights in the areas of business-to-business marketing, public relations and public affairs, consumer advertising, shopper marketing and digital/direct/relationship marketing. EMA has offices in Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse and Albany, N.Y.; Cincinnati; Charlotte, N.C.; and Atlanta, EMA serves clients throughout the United States. EMA also serves many of its clients through thenetworkone, the world's largest independent network of advertising, creative, digital, media and marketing agencies covering 65 countries. EMA belongs to the American Association of Advertising Agencies and IPREX, a worldwide partnership of independent public relations firms. EMA has more than 250 professionals and 2012 capatalized billings of $236 million. Visit www.mower.com for more information.
